Matt wrote:I think it's strange that you are asking for a gun for a small framed girl - and you specifically mention that you don't want something heavy. Yet, you rule out 3 very viable options, while saying that you've narrowed it down to 3 very heavy options.
This.
The M4 is a perfect starter gun for anyone, and a plastic bodied model will be very lightweight. The G36, I could see the issue. Very light, but the stock is either all the way in, or all the way out. That being said, my 5'6" wife took about 5 seconds to figure out the G36k.
My confusion is that she eliminated the M4, but she's okay with the SCAR? They are, for all intents and purposes, the same gun. Once you boil away the cosmetics (is a monolithic rail really that unique?) its a M4 with a folding stock.
P90 I could understand. The ergonomics are kind of funky, and the mags are bulky. Not completely useless, but kind of odd.
AUG is a poor choice. The fixed shoulder length might not be the best thing for someone trying to figure out whats comfortable.
That being said, my wife was in the same predicament a little while ago, and I suggested, since she didn't like the M4 (she doesn't like the way you release the mag) that she get a CYMA AK-74, and she's fairly satisfied with it.
I'm curious, I am, what the logic was for excluding certain guns. The P90 is obvious. The M4 being excluded but the SCAR not be excluded makes no sense, unless she's just in it for the stock. In which case, go for a plastic body SCAR. If she doesn't like folding stocks (and some people don't) and she excludes the G36, but again keeps the SCAR, that makes no sense, and makes the M4 exclusion make even less sense.
MP5. Sure, I could see that. You'd have to go with an SD with a tightbore running through the suppressor, but the wire stocks are kind of uncomfortable for some. The folding stock is nice, but thats the same issue as the G36. The fixed stock is my favorite, but might not be the right length for her.
I've found weird things that don't make sense when it comes to ergonomics, though, so you never know. Have her try an AK-74, see what she thinks.
The King Of al-Talk. Hey, at least I'm not a troll.
My dog wouldn't know what to do with a duck if she caught it, but she's cute. And hates Mexicans. +1!