Snake Doc wrote:Why can we not use both of the SEALs and S.W.A.T's tactics?...
Okay. Here's a rough off-the-cuff answer:
Because they are mutually exclusive? LE uses an entry stack that is genrally about, I dunno, 12 guys to dump a room. With flashbangs, and a lot of yelling, and generally enters with the stated goal of restraining the bad guys as the priority. Arrests, Miranda rights, Due Process and all that jazz. Typically, they initiate a breach with a battering ram, toss a couple of NFDDs in, and swarm the place bodyslamming people to the ground. Generally, the guys they go after are strapped with pistols, and maybe the rare AK / shotgun / AR. Usually, a SWAT entry will put a 12-man stack in on one bad guy. SWAT is about having more good guys than bad guys and dominating the situation.
Military entries, on the other hand, tend to be a smaller element taking down a bigger element. The bad guys tend to have a predominance of automatic weapons, and the motivation to use these weapons. Military CQB tends to be significantly higher on the lethality scale. Guys with guns generally get a bullet to the face on general principle unless they are a specific target or they are caught off-guard enough to be captured without risking the lives of the entry team.
SWAT units tend to move into an area that has been secured by local law enforcement. SEALs slip into an enemy or potentially hostile area and take down their targets without the benefit of having a secure perimetr to set up in close at hand.
If you train to SEAL standards, you are training to shoot bad guys in the face without warning. If you train to SWAT standards, you train to put suspects on the ground, search them, zip-strip them and read them their rights unless you absolutely have to shoot them. See an issue here yet?
LE snipers shoot, on average, 70 meters when they end an engagement. That's a seven with a single zero following it. That is the no-shit real-world number. SEALs? 10 times that distance. And generally, the SWAT guys don't have to worry about countersniper fire.
SWAT units don't have to worry about indrect fire most of the time. They don't have the option to use a LAW or AT-4 to open a doorway intoa compound. They don't have the ability to call in CAS or arty. Or use a HMG to chew through walls to hit the bad guys.On the other hand, they generally have medevac on-scene, with a quality health care facility a matter of minutes away. And when they finish their mission, exfil is a matter of walking back ttheir staging area, stripping off their armor, and shooting the shit while sipping a latté.
Doing either one justice wuld pretty much require a full-time commitment as well as finding qualfied instructors who are willing to offer instruction in paramilitary tactics to teenagers (good luck!). Doing both at once? I can't see how it could be done without developing multiple personality disorders.