Bad Karma wrote:Steve wrote:Throw the dump pouch in the trash, mount your secondary in a SERPA drop leg.
Why? Just curious. Seems like weird advice to give considering how useful DPs are. I use mine almost every game I attend and I know 90% of SOTA does as well.
Policing evidence in a scenario? Dump pouch it!
Engaged in heavy fire and need to quickly reload, but don't want to throw your mags in the mud? Dump pouch it!
Found someone's lost gear and need to take it to the admin booth? Dump pouch it!
Generally speaking, there are two types of reloads. Deliberate reloads, where you have a few seconds / minutes / hours to swap mags, and hasty reloads, where you are under fire, or expect to be in the next instant.
If you need a new mag right this second, then worrying about where the old one ends up is pretty worthless, really. Just drop the spent mag, and recover it later (assuming you come out on top in the exchange). Conversely, if you have half of forever to reload, take the few extra seconds to replace the empty in a mag carrier.
Dump pouches rattle, hang up on stuff, and generally get in the way. Plus, if you are taking the time to place a mag in a dump pouch during a hasty reload, that is a second or two that is not spent bringing your primary back up and into the fight. So, specific to magazines and the reloading process, dump pouches are atrocious.
Now, a folding dump pouch and a cargo pocket full of gallon sized ziplock bags can be remarkably useful for real life / scenario play. But not for magazines. I run one of the 5.11 folding dump pouches on the back of my armor at the 7 o'clock position when I am out playing Army one weekend a month and two weeks in the summer. I generally unfold it, line it with a ziplock, and then fold it back up. Folded up, it's about the same dimensions as a single m-4 mag pouch. If I have to do EPW handling, I can unfold the dump pouch, do my search, and put everything I pull off of the target into the dump pouch. When I'm done with the search, I just pull the ziplock out, seal it, and set it behind the guy. Replace the ziplock, and on to round two, rinsing and repeating as necessary. But the only way a magazine is seeing the inside of that pouch is if I pulled it off somebody else, and only after the shooting is done.